Is Board and Batten Siding Worth It in New Jersey?

Owens CorningPreferred Contractor

CertainTeedSidingMaster

14 Counties Served400+ Towns Across NJ

★★★★★ Rated 5 stars on Google

NJ HIC13VH14050100

For a lot of New Jersey homes, yes. Board and batten siding is one of the easiest ways to make a plain or dated house look current, and in vinyl it holds up to our weather without any painting. It isn’t the right fit for every house, though, and how well it turns out depends heavily on the wall prep and the trim around it.

We just finished two board and batten homes this fall, one in Byram in Sussex County and one in Englewood Cliffs in Bergen County. They looked completely different when they were done. Here’s what board and batten is, where it works, the details that make or break it, and how to decide if it belongs on your house. If you already know you want it, call Nail Force at (973) 713-1053 for a free siding estimate.

What Board and Batten Siding Actually Is

The style goes back to barns and farm buildings: wide vertical boards nailed side by side, with a thin strip, the batten, covering each seam to keep the weather out. Today it’s mostly a design choice. The tall, repeating lines make a house look taller and more tailored than standard horizontal lap siding does.

On most New Jersey homes we install it in vinyl. Royal makes its Board & Batten profile in a wide range of colors, including deep shades like Tree Moss. CertainTeed offers Board & Batten vertical siding in several widths too. The panels have a wood-grain texture and the batten is molded right in, so you get the look of real boards without any scraping, painting or rot.

You can also get the look in fiber cement or engineered wood. Those are heavier, need paint over time and cost more to install. For most homeowners who want the style without the upkeep, vinyl is the practical choice.

Where Board and Batten Looks Best

Board and batten isn’t limited to farmhouses. Here’s where we see it work best:

• Modern farmhouse. White board and batten with black trim, black gutters and a dark roof is the look most people have in mind, and it’s exactly what we did in Englewood Cliffs.
• Ranches and split-levels. Vertical lines add height to a long, low house and make it feel less stretched out.
• Capes and colonials as an accent. Board and batten on the gables, dormers or a front bump-out, with horizontal siding on the rest of the house, adds character without changing the whole style.
• Homes surrounded by trees. Deep greens and earth tones blend with the setting. The Tree Moss house in Byram sits in the woods and looks like it belongs there.
• Additions and garages. It can tie a new addition to the main house, or set it apart on purpose.

Where we’re more careful: very traditional homes in neighborhoods where every house has clapboard, and houses with lots of small, oddly spaced windows. Vertical lines show every window that’s off-center, so we’ll mock it up and talk it through before you commit.

Two Houses, Two Completely Different Looks

Both of this fall’s jobs started with an Owens Corning roof and finished with Royal board and batten. Here’s how much the color and trim choices changed the result.

Byram, Sussex County: Tree Moss with white trim. The homeowners chose Tree Moss, a deep green with a gray undertone. We framed every window in white aluminum picture frame trim, put white super corners on the outside edges, and installed hidden vented soffit with new 6-inch white seamless gutters. With an Owens Corning Duration roof in Onyx Black on top, the white trim makes the green stand out.

Englewood Cliffs, Bergen County: white with black trim. This one went the other way: white Royal board and batten walls, black soffit, black fascia and 6-inch black seamless gutters under an Onyx Black roof. It’s high contrast and very modern, and the black outlines every edge of the house.

Same siding profile, opposite looks. That’s why we talk through the trim and soffit colors as carefully as the siding color itself.

The Details That Make or Break Board and Batten

Vertical siding is less forgiving than horizontal lap siding. Every wavy wall, crooked corner and sloppy cut is easier to see. These are the things we focus on:

• A flat, solid wall underneath. CertainTeed’s installation guide says the key requirement for its Board & Batten is a smooth, level, rigid substrate such as plywood or OSB. On older homes, that can mean new sheathing or furring in spots before the siding goes on.
• Layout before the first panel. We plan where the battens will land at windows, doors and corners so the lines stay even and you don’t get a skinny sliver of panel next to a window.
• Clean trim at every opening. Picture frame trim around windows and doors gives vertical siding a finished edge. Bent aluminum or wide vinyl trim is what separates a custom look from a builder-grade one.
• Corners that match the style. Wide super corners hold up better and look more substantial on board and batten than narrow standard corner posts.
• Room to move. Vinyl still expands and contracts when it runs vertically. Panels are nailed loosely in the slot and given clearance at the top and bottom trim so they don’t buckle in summer.
• Water management at the bottom. The base of the wall and the tops of windows need proper flashing and trim so water running down the vertical grooves is directed out, not behind the siding.

Don’t Forget the Soffit, Fascia and Gutters

On a board and batten house, the roofline frames the whole look. Old, stained soffit or dented gutters stand out even more against new vertical siding. That’s why most of our board and batten jobs include new soffit and fascia, plus new 6-inch seamless gutters in a matching or contrasting color.

Vented soffit matters too. Your attic pulls fresh air in through the soffit and lets it out at the ridge. Hidden vented soffit, like we used in Byram, keeps that airflow going without visible vent strips, which helps protect the roof from heat and moisture. If you’re replacing siding, it’s the best time to get the soffit and gutters right. Learn more on our seamless gutter services page.

Board and Batten vs. Regular Horizontal Siding

Here’s the honest comparison, so you can decide what matters most to you:

• Look: Board and batten reads modern, custom and taller. Horizontal lap siding reads classic and traditional.
• Prep: Board and batten needs a flatter wall and more careful layout. Horizontal siding is more forgiving on older, uneven walls.
• Cost: Board and batten usually costs somewhat more to install because of the extra prep and trim. Using it as an accent on gables keeps the cost closer to a standard job.
• Upkeep: In vinyl, both need little more than an occasional rinse. No painting either way.
• Mixing: They pair well. Horizontal siding on the main walls with board and batten up high is one of the most popular combinations we install.

If you’re also comparing vinyl siding lines, our breakdown of CertainTeed Mainstreet vs. Monogram explains how panel quality affects the finished wall. And if you’re not sure your current siding needs replacing yet, read siding repair vs. replacement.

Why Northern NJ Homeowners Choose Nail Force for Board and Batten

Board and batten is a detail job, and that’s how we treat it. Before we quote, we check the walls, talk through colors, trim and soffit, and spell out exactly what’s included: siding line, color, trim style, corners, wall prep, soffit and gutters, all in writing.

Nail Force Contracting is a CertainTeed SidingMaster contractor and an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, licensed and insured in New Jersey, and five-star rated on Google. Our team brings 11 years of combined experience on Northern New Jersey exteriors. We install Royal siding, CertainTeed siding and more. See our full siding services and vinyl siding installation.

NJ HIC #13VH14050100. Licensed and insured. Free siding estimates across Northern New Jersey.

Board and Batten Siding FAQs